Showing posts with label dogmas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dogmas. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 28, 2026

Brokenness AND Repair

    “The physical world in which we live … is only part of an inconceivably vast system of worlds. Most of these worlds are spiritual in their essence … they exist in different dimensions of being.” Rabbi Adin Steinsaltz, “The Thirteen Petalled Rose”

    “The old temple of Western religion is burning … We are seeking a new temple, one that links our inherited traditions with our forgotten ancestors.”
Jill Hammer, “The Hebrew Priestess.”

    “The October 7th slaughter of her fellow Jews, and the Israeli invasion of Gaza, deeply shook Jill Hammer and her wife Shoshana, whose father survived Auschwitz and fought in Israel’s war of independence. Hammer looked drawn and exhausted when we spoke a few days after the massacre. I asked if there was anything in her belief system that would allow her to digest what had happened. 
    ‘In the Kabbalah, the world is a broken place,’ she said almost forlornly. ‘And the whole idea of tikkun, repair, which is at the heart of Kabbalah, assumes that our world is broken. And it makes the mystical assumption that the small acts of repair that we do are a way of slowly piecing back together that broken world. I don’t think that’s a bad way to look at the human condition.’ 
    As we spoke, thousands of human beings were being killed each day by other human beings. Divine intervention was not the answer, Hammer explained sadly. The onus, she said, was on us. ‘The Kabbalah assumes that there isn’t some deity looking at this from some perfect realm, but that the transcendent is itself implicated in all of this brokenness
and also cannot escape it. And for me, that’s a much more appealing theology than there’s some God in some perfect space who could fix all this if only God would bother.’ 
    I could see a change in her face as she tried to compartmentalize her human pain and reconnect with her spiritual self. ‘As long as we live in bodies, there is the potential that we will fight over things, that we will hurt each other.’ The Kabbalah taught this was the inevitable result of imbalance between gevuruth, strength, and chesed, loving-kindness, in the world. Strength without compassion, she explained, was the root of evil. ‘It’s like a cancerous growth that comes out of gevuruth. Then you get acts of ego and cruelty and separation
.’ 
    But
it was on the idea of Jews as the ‘chosen people’ that she parted with her beloved Kabbalah. ‘I certainly feel the Jewish people have a unique history and perhaps destiny, but the Kabbalah’s argument that Jews are engaged in this work of tikkun and other people are at best neutral and at worst agents of brokenness, that’s not a thing I would want to adopt.’ That view just fueled narcissism and the quest for strength without compassion. Peace might be out of reach, but restoration of balance – which would be the first step – was at the center of her prayers. ‘I understand that there are things that may not move in response to my prayer, but maybe there are some things that can.’” 
    Lawrence Pintak “Lessons from the Mountaintop. Ten Modern Mystics and Their Extraordinary Lives.” Sentient Publications, 2025.

    Perspective, as in most things, is all-important when the concept of "chosen people" comes up. Non-Jews, might immediately feel excluded, inferior, second class etc. However, ALL the other theistic religions ALSO dogmatically state that their specific religion is the ONLY way to heaven - they may not call themselves "chosen people" but religious exclusivism, no matter how thickly sugar-coated, excludes anyone outside the club just the same.
    Narcissism
still rages like a wildfire in politics, but mercifully, it's causing rigid, ossified, religious dogmas - like religious exclusivism - to crumble.


“We live in a moment of disruption, death, and rebirth.  
What’s dying is an old civilization and mindset of ‘me.’  
What is being born is less clear but in no way less significant… It’s a future that requires us to tap into a deeper level  
of our humanity
, of who we really are,  
and who we want to be as a society.  
It’s a shift that requires us to expand our thinking  
from the head to the heart.  
It is a shift from an ego-system awareness  
that cares about the well-being of me  
to an eco-system awareness  
that cares about the well-being of all,  
including myself.” 
Otto Scharmer


“God dwells within you, 
as you.”
Muktananda

"The answer my friend, is blowing in the wind ..."

 

Sunday, November 13, 2016

Membership's Benefits ... and Drawbacks

     Sometimes we enthusiastically join, support and become strongly identified with certain groups. How completely we become identified with & transformed by the group depends on us, as well as the group. Our level of psychosociospiritual development determines the type of group(s) we wish to join. There's a very broad range of groups from which to choose: from sports teams, charities, political parties, professions, unions, the armed forces, religions, nations, ethnic groups, to outlaw gangs, etc.
     Not surprisingly, we're in a very different place in our life if we choose to join & identify with, say the Hell's Angels instead of Save the Whales. Besides different activities, one group may demand strict obedience ("dogmatic"), while another may be laid back & informal ("liberal"). Interestingly, many of us, at a certain point in our lives, are strongly drawn to dogmatic groups that completely take over our thinking, behavior - our whole lives. The very same person who's a peace-loving humanitarian in their 60s, could have, in their teens, enthusiastically enlisted for combat duty to fight "the enemy" of the day.
     When we feel lost, empty, like a nobody, marginalized, hopeless, angry, without any sense of belonging, as soon as we join a dogmatic group, we instantly feel proud, connected, accepted, have both an identity and a home. A dogmatic group has a strong distinctive brand, and we're thrilled to be branded, wear the uniform, fly the flag, repeat the slogans. For many, this means a radically-improved quality of life. There's no looking back at what we might have given up - our immediate assumption is nothing, since they had nothing. Group-think is demanded and easy to go along with - easier than thinking for oneself. One develops very strong, almost unbreakable emotional attachment to such groups. Many dogmatic groups explicitly teach that leaving the group has catastrophic consequences for the individual - shunning, court martial, eternal hell-fire. So reason is rarely successful against such powerful emotions to extricate oneself (or another) from dogmatic groups. Members tend to be paranoid, and may respond violently to any criticism - feeling as if their very life were being threatened.
     But human evolution of consciousness is an entirely natural process, whereas the core basis of dogmatic groups is a set of fixed ideas - dogmas. Most of us simply outgrow dogmas. 
     "Cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time; performs an action that is contradictory to their beliefs, ideas, or values; or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas or values. (But) humans strive for internal consistency. An individual who experiences inconsistency tends to become psychologically uncomfortable, and is motivated to try to reduce this dissonance, as well as actively avoid situations and information likely to increase it." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance 
     So as we mature psychosociospiritually, cognitive dissonance increases. The question then is how much authenticity can I tolerate suppressing while I'm with my dogmatic group? This is a wrenching, quasi-life-or-death decision - a form of ego death, since the group for many of us is/was our core identity. But living a lie - a "divided life", is for some of us, deadening, soul-destroying.
     When we quietly observe the mind during meditation, we notice a huge amount of self-talk - mostly transient, unnecessary ego noise. Our real identity is beyond all this noise: words, concepts, including all dogmas. When the noise from our own or our group's ego settles down, we touch authenticity, freedom.
     


Monday, November 25, 2013

Attachment to People, Memories, Concepts, Theories, Dogmas ...


      "One of the basic tenets of Bowlby's attachment theory is interactions with significant others who are available & supportive in times of stress facilitate the formation of a sense of a "secure base," or ... felt security. This sense can be viewed as the cognitive-affective aspect of an interpersonal prototype or script. 
     Theoretically, the script includes something like the following if-then propositions: If I encounter an obstacle or become distressed, I can approach a significant other for help; he or she is likely to be available and supportive; I will experience relief and comfort as a result of proximity to this person; I can then return to other activities. 
     In Bowlby's terms, the sense of having a secure base provides an individual with a framework for maintaining well-being, formulating effective emotion-regulation devices, developing positive models of the self & others, and engaging in exploration & risk-taking activities.
     Although the sense of having a secure base may be formed during early interactions with primary caregivers, Bowlby contended that every meaningful interaction with significant others throughout life may affect a person's beliefs about others' availability & supportiveness. Moreover, although the sense of having a secure base may be quite general, it is also common for people to develop relationship-specific beliefs organized around actual experiences with a specific partner. These beliefs do not necessarily fit with the more general, chronic sense of having (or not having) a secure base. In fact, like every cognitive-affective representation, the sense of having a secure base can be contextually activated by actual or imagined encounters with available & responsive others, even among persons who have chronic doubts about their secure base." 
       Mikulincer M, Shaver PR. Attachment theory and intergroup bias: Evidence that priming the secure base schema attenuates negative reactions to out-groups. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2001; 81(1): 97–115.

     "There are two remarkable things about the empirical findings summarized (in the paper above). One is that meaningful benefits emerge not only from actual secure attachments in real-life relationships, but also from the mere activation of attachment-connoting concepts into working memory. The second remarkable finding is that these beneficial effects are found across such a diverse range of meaningful outcomes. The cognitive priming of attachment security makes people healthier. It leads them to be more compassionate and helpful to others. It reduces prejudice. Future research will, no doubt, discover yet more benefits that emerge from the simple priming of attachment security. I’m tempted to believe that a sense of secure attachment may be the psychological equivalent of a broad-spectrum antibiotic — a sort of universal antidote to everything that ails us."
 

       Schaller M. Is secure attachment the antidote to everything that ails us? Psychological Inquiry 2007; 18(3): 191-193.

       There's a problem with this "universal antidote." Wisdom traditions agree that serious evolution of consciousness begins with LETTING GO of ATTACHMENT - to everything, without exception.